WordPress Community Commentary

WordPress Community Commentary

By The WordPress Helpers 2 Comments

WordPress Community Commentary

Of all the things that go into successful use of WordPress, the one that matters most isn’t technical. It isn’t social, per se. It isn’t even about how your WordPress web site looks. The most important part of WordPress success is WordPress Community Commentary.

This isn’t a rant of any sort; it’s a lesson. Whether you’re building a community of your own or joining one, you need to manage the way your profile and your content get seen and used. I was reminded of this both earlier today and earlier this week, and it made me think back to a couple of pieces I wrote at Answer Guy Central; you need to own your own cloud, and we’re all narrowcasting.

The thing that happened early this week was that I got a chance to be involved in a lively WordPress Community Commentary that included the author of a new comments management plug-in called Postmatic. I’d come across Postmatic before on Tom McFarlin‘s site, but this was special. We’ve joined the Postmatic beta program, and you should see it here very soon.

This morning, I found the piece you see linked below. It rocks. Or at least I think it does; 64 Ways to Think About a News Homepage encapsulates what we’re trying to do here; we know you don’t always know what you’re looking for and we’re trying to present the perfect environment for you to find whatever—and whatever type of—WordPress Resource you’re seeking.

That’s hard! Speaking as a guy with a long media and journalism background who’s watched those industries morph into something that’s barely recognizable, this isn’t just important to our goals at The WordPress Helpers but has been keeping me awake nights. For quite some time now.

How DO you give people what they want AND maintain control?

That’s the $64,000 question (hmmm … 64 is the number du jour, isn’t it?), and when I responded to the piece on 64 Ways to Think About a News Homepage the folks at Medium “got me”; it seemed I was leaving a comment, but what they got me to do was write a whole new article. That would be fine if I’d known it (it would have been longer; it might have been what you’re reading right now), but until I hit “post” I didn’t realize that Medium had tricked me into contributing to their SEO machine, and provided no attribution on the original piece.

Wait, it gets better. On my piece, there’s a link back to the piece that I started at and had so enjoyed. So the juice flows in one direction; that’s not community, its manipulation.

You can create your community and manage WordPress Community Commentary any way you like—and of course there are always business goals behind your efforts. But if you ask people to participate and they realize there’s nothing in it for them, they’ll go away. And Medium, you’ve just shown a whole new reason people’s time is better spent on their web site than on yours.

Source: Medium 
64 Ways to Think About Content
Free Stuff!
No charge. No SPAM. Unsubscribe any time.

We'll send a weekly email with the latest information, recommendations, quick WordPress tips and more. We're serious about privacy and won't spam you or sell your information.

Or if you prefer, subscribe to our RSS feed. Stay up to date, live!

<center>The WordPress Helpers: Making WordPress Work</center>
WordPress and Community Commentary
Article Title:
WordPress and Community Commentary
Who benefits from the WordPress Community and Community Commentary? It should be "everyone", but ... it had better be you.


  1. Hey there Jeff,

    First, thanks for taking part in what was a very lively comment section a couple of days ago around the Postmatic beta, and for bringing some very valid points around UX, future features, etc. That, for me, is what a great community discussion is all about – everyone has something to offer, and no-one has a louder voice than anyone else.

    This statement in particular stands out for me in your post (of many great statements, I should add!):

    How DO you give people what they want AND maintain control?

    And therein lies the nub. Yes, we want to encourage participation, we want to encourage a lively interaction, and we want to make the experience enjoyable. But in doing so, do we let go of all the things we put in place to make these things happen to start with, and change to something we’re not?

    An intriguing conundrum for sure. Here’s to future thoughts on where it’s all going. 🙂

    1. Author

      And thank YOU, Danny, both for hosting that lively set-to, and for being the guy who got me together with Jason. I REALLY hope he can figure out a way to address some of the things that came up, because if he does, that thing will genuinely make a lot of people’s lives better.

      Yowza. I really did just say that about a piece of software, didn’t I ?

Leave a Comment